Secret Girlfriend: First-Season Finale Preview

A decision must finally be made during Secret Girlfriend‘s November 11 first-season finale.

You — meaning the unseen dude observing everything — must choose one woman…

…either crazy and determined ex-girlfriend Mandy or sane and fun-loving new romantic interest Jessica. Or could the hot neighbor be in the mix, too? Ahhh … hormones.

But first, there’s time to find a couple of women for Phil and Sam, and Mandy also begins acting not-crazy to win unseen guy back. Will it work?

Check out two finale sneak peeks below: Benching Yourseslf (sloppy firsts as a method of hooking up) and Who Will You Choose? (all the women encountered this season).

Secret Girlfriend airs Wednesdays on Comedy Central at 10:30pm ET.